What's Behind Otter Tail's Recent Earnings Miss

Key Takeaways

• Otter Tail Corporation (OTTR) recently missed Q4 GAAP EPS and revenue estimates, primarily due to a challenging manufacturing segment.
• Despite the short-term miss, the company's 2026 guidance, driven by robust electric utility investments and rate base growth, points to a stable future.
• OTTR's attractive valuation relative to peers and consistent dividend growth make it a compelling consideration for long-term, income-focused investors, despite near-term analyst caution.

What's Behind Otter Tail's Recent Earnings Miss?

Otter Tail Corporation, a diversified holding company with interests in electric utility and manufacturing, recently reported a mixed bag for its fourth quarter and full-year 2025 results. The company announced Q4 GAAP EPS of $1.23, falling short of analyst expectations by $0.05. Revenue for the quarter also slightly missed the mark, coming in at $308.09 million against an anticipated $311.15 million, reflecting a 1.6% year-over-year increase but still a slight disappointment for the market.

The primary culprit behind this earnings and revenue miss appears to be the manufacturing segment. This division faced significant headwinds throughout 2025, experiencing soft end-market demand and a notable 6% decline in sales volumes. For the full year 2025, the manufacturing segment's revenues decreased by 8.2% to $314.5 million, underscoring the pressure on profitability from this part of the business. Management acknowledged these challenges but highlighted efforts to align cost structures, positioning the segment for a recovery when market conditions improve.

In stark contrast, the electric utility segment demonstrated remarkable resilience and growth. This core business saw its operating revenues increase by a healthy 8.1% to $566.76 million in 2025, while net income for the segment rose by 7.3% to $97.59 million. This strong performance was largely driven by higher electric sales and effective fuel recovery mechanisms, showcasing the stability and essential nature of Otter Tail's utility operations. Overall, the company still managed to report a net income of $275.9 million for 2025, a 6.6% increase from 2024, demonstrating that the utility segment's strength largely offset the manufacturing segment's struggles.

How Does Otter Tail's 2026 Guidance Shape Up?

Looking ahead, Otter Tail Corporation has initiated its 2026 diluted earnings per share guidance, projecting a range of $5.22 to $5.62. This guidance reflects a cautious yet optimistic outlook, with a projected return on equity of 12% at the midpoint. The company's strategic focus remains firmly on its electric utility operations, which are expected to contribute approximately 49% of the total earnings in 2026, solidifying its role as the primary growth engine.

The electric segment is anticipated to see a robust 14% increase in segment earnings for 2026. This growth is underpinned by several key factors, including returns generated from a projected 14% increase in the average rate base. Furthermore, the company expects to benefit from interim revenues commencing January 1, 2026, stemming from a general rate case filed in Minnesota, alongside anticipated final rates from its South Dakota general rate case. These regulatory approvals are crucial for ensuring stable and predictable revenue streams for the utility.

Otter Tail's long-term capital expenditure plans further reinforce the positive outlook for the electric segment. The company has outlined an ambitious $2.05 billion capital spending plan from 2026 through 2030. These investments are strategically directed towards high-quality projects, including renewable energy initiatives, transmission upgrades, and other infrastructure enhancements aimed at providing safe, reliable, and increasingly clean electric service. This commitment to modernizing its grid and expanding its renewable footprint is expected to drive a five-year rate base compounded annual growth rate of 10%, providing a clear path for sustained utility earnings.

While the manufacturing segment faced challenges in 2025, management projects a 7% increase in segment earnings for 2026. This modest recovery is based on assumptions of flat to modest increases in sales volumes within its contract metal fabrication business, as certain end markets are expected to remain challenged. The company's proactive measures to align its cost structure are expected to help maintain competitiveness and position the segment for a swift recovery once broader market conditions improve.

Is OTTR's Valuation Attractive After the Dip?

Otter Tail Corporation's stock currently trades at $88.16, having experienced some volatility around its recent earnings announcement. Despite the Q4 miss, a deeper dive into its valuation metrics suggests that OTTR might present an attractive opportunity for value-oriented investors, especially when compared to its industry peers. The company's trailing twelve-month (TTM) P/E ratio stands at 13.30, which looks quite favorable when stacked against the US Electric Utilities industry average of 22.4x. This significant discount suggests that the market may be undervaluing Otter Tail relative to its sector.

However, a closer look reveals a nuanced picture. While OTTR's P/E is lower than the industry average, its current P/E of 13.2x (as per Simply Wall St) is considered expensive when compared to its estimated "Fair Price-To-Earnings Ratio" of 11.1x. This indicates that while it's cheaper than the average utility, it might still be trading above its intrinsic P/E based on its own forecast earnings growth and risk factors. The stock's current price of $88.16 is also trading above Simply Wall St's estimate of its future cash flow value of $1.27, which is a significant discrepancy that warrants caution.

Comparing OTTR to specific peers further highlights its relative value. For instance, MGE Energy (MGEE) trades at 22.5x forward P/E, Hawaiian Electric Industries (HE) at 25.8x, and Portland General Electric (POR) at 20x. In this context, Otter Tail's 13.2x P/E appears to be a compelling discount, especially considering its robust utility segment. The market capitalization of $3.69 billion positions it as a mid-cap player within the utility space, offering a blend of stability and potential for growth.

The overall analyst consensus on OTTR is currently a "Hold," based on 7 analysts, with a consensus price target of $81.00. This target represents a potential downside of 5.85% from the current price, suggesting that Wall Street analysts are not yet convinced of significant upside potential. This contrasts with the company's strong historical performance, with the stock up 92% over the last 5 years, outperforming the broader market's 74% return (excluding dividends). This divergence between historical performance, relative valuation, and current analyst sentiment creates an interesting dynamic for investors to consider.

What Are the Key Risks and Opportunities for OTTR?

Investing in Otter Tail Corporation, like any equity, comes with its own set of risks and opportunities that warrant careful consideration. On the opportunity side, the company's strong commitment to its electric utility segment is a significant tailwind. The $2.05 billion capital expenditure plan for 2026-2030, focused on renewable energy and transmission projects, positions OTTR for long-term, regulated growth. This investment strategy is expected to drive a 10% compounded annual growth rate in its rate base, providing a predictable earnings stream characteristic of stable utility operations. The recent 10% increase in its quarterly dividend, announced in January 2026, further underscores management's confidence and commitment to returning value to shareholders, with a current dividend yield of 2.4%.

However, the manufacturing segment remains a notable risk factor. While management projects a 7% earnings increase for 2026, this is predicated on a flat to modest increase in sales volumes, indicating continued challenges in certain end markets. A prolonged downturn in industrial demand or increased competition could hinder this segment's recovery, potentially dragging on consolidated earnings. The company's diversified nature, while offering some insulation, means that weakness in one segment can still impact overall performance.

Regulatory risk is another inherent factor for utility companies. While rate cases in Minnesota and South Dakota are expected to contribute to 2026 earnings, adverse regulatory decisions or delays in approvals could impact the electric segment's profitability. Furthermore, the substantial capital expenditures, while growth-oriented, require careful financing. The issuance of $100.0 million in long-term debt in 2025 to fund investments highlights the company's reliance on external financing, which could become more expensive in a rising interest rate environment.

From a technical perspective, OTTR's stock price has shown a bullish trend recently, with its price above its 5, 20, and 50-day exponential moving averages. This suggests buying pressure and positive momentum in the short term. However, the average analyst price target of $81.00 implies a downside, creating a potential disconnect between technical indicators and fundamental analyst views. Investors should weigh the long-term stability and growth potential of the utility business against the cyclicality of manufacturing and the cautious analyst sentiment.

Is Otter Tail a Buy, Hold, or Sell for Value Investors?

For value-oriented investors, Otter Tail Corporation presents a complex but potentially rewarding proposition. The recent Q4 earnings and revenue miss, while disappointing, was largely attributable to the manufacturing segment, which has historically been more volatile than the stable utility business. The core electric utility segment continues to perform strongly, with robust capital expenditure plans and favorable rate case outcomes expected to drive predictable growth in 2026 and beyond. This dual-segment structure offers a unique blend of stability from the regulated utility and cyclical upside (or downside) from manufacturing.

The company's valuation, with a TTM P/E of 13.30, appears attractive when compared to the broader Electric Utilities industry average of 22.4x. This discount suggests that the market may not be fully appreciating the long-term stability and growth prospects of its utility operations. Furthermore, Otter Tail's consistent dividend growth, including the recent 10% increase, makes it an appealing choice for income-focused investors seeking reliable payouts in a defensive sector. The dividend payout ratio of 30.7% indicates ample room for future increases, supported by a healthy earnings yield of 7.5%.

However, the "Hold" consensus from analysts and the average price target of $81.00 (a 5.85% downside from the current price of $88.16) cannot be ignored. This cautious sentiment likely reflects concerns about the manufacturing segment's ongoing challenges and the potential for slower overall growth compared to some pure-play utilities. While the electric segment is strong, its projected 14% earnings increase for 2026 is partially offset by the more modest 7% for manufacturing, leading to a consolidated EPS guidance range of $5.22 to $5.62 that is lower than the TTM EPS of $6.63. This implies a period of consolidation or slight decline in earnings before the long-term capital investments fully bear fruit.

Ultimately, for investors with a long-term horizon and an appreciation for stable, dividend-paying companies in essential sectors, OTTR could be a compelling "Buy" on any further dips. The current price offers a reasonable entry point given its relative valuation and the strong foundation of its utility business. However, those seeking aggressive growth or immediate upside might find the analyst "Hold" rating and the current price target a reason for caution. It's a stock that requires patience, allowing the utility investments to mature and the manufacturing segment to navigate its cyclical challenges.

The Road Ahead for Otter Tail

Otter Tail Corporation stands at an interesting juncture, navigating short-term manufacturing headwinds while laying a strong foundation for long-term utility growth. The company's strategic investments in its electric segment, coupled with a commitment to shareholder returns through dividends, paint a picture of resilience. Investors should monitor the manufacturing segment's recovery and the progress of its significant capital expenditure plan.

The current valuation offers a compelling entry for those prioritizing stability and income, but the cautious analyst sentiment suggests a need for patience. Otter Tail's journey will be defined by its ability to execute on its utility expansion while effectively managing the cyclical nature of its manufacturing operations.

---

Want deeper research on any stock? Try Kavout Pro for AI-powered analysis, smart signals, and more. Already a member? Add credits to run more research.