Comparing SQ and SOFI: Which Fintech Stock is the Better Investment?

Jan 31, 2024 | Investment Ideas

The fintech industry has been a hotbed of innovation and growth, attracting investors looking to capitalize on the digital transformation of financial services. Among the numerous players in this space, Block, Inc. (NYSE: SQ), formerly known as Square, and SoFi Technologies (NASDAQ: SOFI) stand out as prominent competitors. This report delves into an in-depth comparison of both stocks to determine which presents a more compelling buy for investors.

    Company Overviews

    Block, Inc., a diversified financial services and technology company, has expanded its offerings well beyond its original card-reader and point-of-sale systems. It now encompasses a broad range of payment and financial services, including the popular Cash App.

    SoFi Technologies, on the other hand, began as a lending company but has since expanded into a full-fledged financial services platform. A significant milestone for the company was obtaining a national bank charter, enhancing its ability to offer a wider array of financial products and services.

    Product Offerings

    Block, Inc. (NYSE: SQ), known for its compact card reader that transformed smartphones into point-of-sale systems, has expanded its product suite to include a broader range of financial services. Block’s ecosystem encompasses payment processing, business lending through Square Capital, and the Cash App, which allows peer-to-peer payments and investment services. Block’s approach has been to provide a cohesive set of tools that empower entrepreneurs and individuals to participate in the economy.

    SoFi Technologies (NASDAQ: SOFI), on the other hand, began as a student loan refinancing company and has since broadened its horizon to offer an array of financial products. This includes personal and home loans, insurance, cash management accounts, and investment platforms. SoFi’s strategy appears to be a one-stop-shop for financial services, aiming to address multiple financial needs of consumers under one umbrella.

    Leadership and Strategic Direction

    Leadership is a critical factor in driving a company’s success, and both SQ and SOFI have notable executives at the helm. Block is led by Jack Dorsey, co-founder of Twitter, whose vision for economic empowerment has been a guiding light for the company’s innovative products and services. Dorsey’s leadership has been instrumental in maintaining Block’s position at the forefront of financial technology.

    SoFi’s leadership, under CEO Anthony Noto, has demonstrated a strong commitment to expanding the company’s product line and increasing its user base. Noto’s experience as a former COO of Twitter and managing director at Goldman Sachs provides a unique blend of technology and finance expertise that has been beneficial in steering SoFi’s strategic direction.

    Financial Performance and Market Position

    Both companies have faced a challenging market environment, with shares of PayPal, Block, and SoFi declining significantly year-to-date. These downturns reflect broader market pressures, particularly for growth stocks in the technology sector.

    Despite this, SoFi has reported impressive earnings, with expansion in its customer base driven by innovative financial offerings. Analysts have given SoFi a Moderate Buy consensus rating, with an average price target suggesting an upside potential. The company’s financials have been well-received, with a recent surge in its stock price attributed to these strong quarterly results.

    Analyst Ratings and Price Targets

    The outlook for SoFi is optimistic, with analysts setting an average 12-month price target of $8.94, a high estimate of $12.00, and a low estimate of $6.50. This suggests that the market sees potential for recovery and growth in SoFi’s stock.

    Block’s stock has also seen an advance, albeit a modest one, of over 5% in 2023. The company has a Moderate Buy consensus rating from analysts, with an average price target indicating a significant upside from its current valuation.

    Market Trends and Fintech Growth

    The fintech market is experiencing rapid growth, with estimates suggesting it could reach $882.30 billion by 2030. This represents a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 17% from 2023. Both SoFi and Block are well-positioned to capitalize on this trend, given their established presence and expanding product offerings.

    Investment Considerations

    When comparing SQ and SOFI, several factors must be considered. Block’s diversified business model and the strength of its Cash App ecosystem position it as a robust player in the fintech space. However, its recent performance has been lackluster compared to SoFi’s more dynamic growth narrative.

    SoFi’s recent earnings have been impressive, and its national bank charter could provide a significant competitive advantage. The company’s focus on expanding its customer base and its innovative product offerings are key drivers of its growth potential.


    Based on the available information and market trends, SoFi Technologies appears to be the more compelling buy for investors. The company’s strong recent performance, coupled with a favorable analyst outlook and the potential upside from its bank charter, position it well for future growth. While Block also presents an attractive investment opportunity with its solid market position and diversified offerings, the momentum and growth prospects of SoFi make it a standout in the fintech sector.

    In conclusion, while both companies are likely to benefit from the expanding fintech market, SoFi’s current trajectory and strategic advantages make it the better buy for those looking to invest in the fintech space.

    To become a better investor with our AI Assistant @

    Send us a Message

    12 + 6 =

    Contact us

    Contact us today to learn more about Kavout's products or services.